Hy-Brasil and Demar: Re-examining a 700 Year Old Mystery

Abraham-Ortelius Map - 1570

Hy-Brasil?
For the uninitiated, Hy-Brasil, along with its near neighbour Demar, has long been said to be a mythical Island, almost cleaved in two by a central river channel running north / south, some 200 miles off the west coast of Ireland in the Atlantic Ocean. Hy-Brasil will be the main focus of this article, although Demar is as equally important, as you will discover at the end of the article.

Paradoxically, whilst Hy-Brasil has appeared on official maps as early as 1325 (shown as Bracile in Angelino Dalorto’s nautical chart), right through to 1872, where it is referenced as Brasil Rock, no person, apart from passing reference in a few anecdotal tales, has ever located it, let alone visit it.

In addition to the name I’ve chosen to adopt for this article, Hy-Brasil, it can also sometimes also be referred to as Bracile, Brazirm, Hy-Brazil, Hy-Breasail, Hy-Breasil and, Sola De Brasil, amongst others.

It has even sometimes been confused with the South American Country of Brazil by some writers, which in itself has been offered as the solution to the Hy-Brasil legend, although perhaps it would be unkind of me to refer to them as lazy researchers.

In part, this confusion has arisen due to some commentators being quick to point out the similarity Brazilian National Flag, a blue globe, halved by a curved band containing a motto, in the centre of the flag. This compares with the shape of the island of Hy Brasil, often depicted by cartographers as circular, divided by a central river channel.

Brazil Flag vs Hy-Brasil Depiction / Comparison
Comparison between the central globe on the Brazilian National Flag (right) and, Hy-Brasil from Joao Teixeira Albernaz 1630 (left) – Library of Congress

Whilst its etymological root is unknown, the name Hy-Brasil is popularly believed to have been derived from the Irish Ui Breasail (descendants Bresail), who are one of the historical clans of north east Ireland.

What can be sure though is Hy-Brasil has been in the human consciousness for almost 700 years. However, the questions remain, are we any nearer to solving the mystery and finally discovering its location or, is it they are forever destined to remain a legend for all eternity?

Hy-Brasil – the Legend, the Myth
Although nowhere near as well known as Plato’s ’lost land’ of Atlantis, first brought to light in his Timaeus and Critias dialogues (written in the fourth Century BC) (1),  Hy-Brasil, has had far less illustrious patrons, featuring ‘only’ in Irish oral myths and ancient histories, as well as possibly the adventures of 6th Century Irish Saints.

The legends of both St Barrind and St Brendan contain accounts of each setting out on voyages, seemingly managing to confirm each other’s accounts of discovering an unnamed island off the West Coast of Ireland. 

However, it was clear that there was a strong belief in the island’s existence as far back as the 12th Century, if not even earlier, with a longstanding oral tradition of a mysterious island, which could only be viewed off the west coast of Ireland for one day, every seven years.

An island that, apart from this one day, was always shrouded in fog and would ‘disappear’ when sailors were brave enough to try and approach it.

Much later, with the advent of the printed press, the story was collated and printed in Irish folklore books, such as Irish Wonders, written by D R McAnally in 1888 or even more recently, in Ellie O’Neill’s 2015 book, The Enchanted Island.

Iin addition, to these undoubtedly ancient Irish oral traditions, there are also several historical reports of sightings that have been documented and, even physical landings on the Island itself.

In the fifteenth Century there was attempts made to find the Island, with several expeditions setting sail from the south west of England, sailing from the port of Bristol.

John Lay left Bristol in 1480 to find the Island without any success, after two months of searching. A year later, in 1481, two vessels, The George and The Trinity sailed from the same port and similarly had no joy in their search.

Tantalisingly, it was reported by a Spanish Diplomat, Pedro de Ayala, in 1497, a decade later, that John Cabot (Italian Navigator and Explorer), whilst based in Bristol, had learnt that local sailors had actually found Hy-Brasil in previous expeditions.

However, it’s the few known written accounts that remain the most intriguing and most well known.

The W. Hamilton Letter (1674)
In 1657, French traveller, Francois de La Boullaye Le Gouz published his memoirs (2) covering his two month visit to Ireland in 1644, thirteen years previously.

Over time, additions to the slim volume were made, by three different authors, which are now included in modern imprints of the memoirs. Fascinatingly, one of these authors discussed the old Irish legends of disappearing islands and included a private discussion of the legend of Hy-Brasil.

The account, a letter written by W Hamilton of Londonderry dated 14th March 1674 and subsequently published by a newspaper in 1675, outlined the discovery of the island, which loomed suddenly out of the early morning mist one day and revealed itself to a Captain John Nisbet (3), an Irish trader, who came across Hy-Brasil whilst on a return voyage to Ireland, laden with wine from France.

Pulling up to the shore, with only a crew of eight, Nisbet instructed half of his men to take a boat, make landfall and establish where exactly they were. The landing party consisted of Alexander Johnson, the ship’s Master, James Ross, the ship’s carpenter and two sailors, each suitably armed with pistols and swords, not sure of what welcome, if any, to expect

Having beached the boat without incident, the four men walked inland and travelled through a small wood, for no more than a mile, before they found themselves in a lush green valley, populated by cattle, horses and sheep.

In the distance they could see a fortified building, which they made their way towards, to enquire as to where they had landed.

Orford Castle Keep, Suffolk, England
NOT a fortified tower from Hy-Brasil

Arriving at the building, they found no one present, so set off up a small hill to continue their exploration. As they ascended the hill, they noted many black rabbits. At this point it’s important to note, it was just black rabbits, not giant or even large black rabbits, as can often be found written in copies of the original account..

Reaching the top of the hill, they looked around them but there was still no sign of a fellow human being, nor any sign of any human habitation, other than the fortified building they had visited earlier.

They continued their exploration for another three hours until deciding to return to their ship.

Once back on board, they informed Nisbet of their lack of success in finding out where they were. It was then decided that all but one of the crew should return to the island, where they would split into two groups, which would enable them to conduct a far more efficient search of the island.

Alas, after several hours searching, both parties met with the same lack of success so, with the night drawing in and the temperature rapidly falling, the seven men made a small fire at the edge of the wood and discussed what they had discovered in their respective searches, as they attempted to warm themselves next to the flames.

As night fell, they were startled by the most terrifying loud noise, a low but powerful rumble, the likes of which they’d never experienced before. It appeared to come from the direction of the fortified building they had discovered in the valley on the other side of the wood earlier in the day.

The noise reverberated across the entire island before slowly subsiding, leaving the men terrified.

Fearing for their lives, they rushed to their boat on the shore as fast as their legs could carry them, in a sense of panic and rowed quickly, using all the strength they could muster, back to their ship.

Once back on board, they attempted to make good their escape from the clutches of the island, but alas, to their great horror, the wind was against them and they found themselves trapped in the shallows, close to the shore from which they’d just left.    

With little other options open to them, they spent the night shivering in their quarters, too scared to sleep, whilst they waited for the wind to turn to a favourable direction.

As the Sun rose the next morning, the night watchman spied a very old, wizened old gentleman, approaching their position from further along the shore. The old man was seen to be accompanied by ten others.

Standing on the shore, opposite the ship, the old man asked the purpose of Nisbet’s visit and invited the crew ashore, speaking Scottish Gaelic, which took the visitors by great surprise. Spotting the crew’s apprehension, the old man assured them no harm would come to the men or their vessel.

Not wishing to take any chances, six of the crew, including the ship’s Master, Alexander Johnson, made landfall fully armed and joined the old man on the shore.

The old man greeted each of the crew one by one, informing them they were the first visitors to the island for over a hundred years.

He went on to tell them the island upon which they had landed was called O’Brazile and both he and his group were the remaining survivors of a much larger group who had been held prisoner in the fortified building by an evil necromancer. When the sailors had called at the building the previous morning, they unknowingly broke the spell holding the prisoners, allowing them finally to escape.

The old man then led the men through the woods, back towards the fortified building, where the sailors immediately noticed that one of the towers on the building appear to have been raised to the ground in a crumbled heap of boulders.

Arriving at the remains of the building, they were met by even more people, who, as the old man had done before, warmly embraced the ship’s crew.

Now feeling confident of their safety, the remaining two crew members still on board the ship were called ashore to join the rest of their crew mates, where they feasted and were richly rewarded for enabling the freedom of the old man and the remaining prisoners.

During the celebrations, the crew were informed that the island was 60 mile long and, 30 miles in breadth and, possessed rich mines of both gold and silver. The island was abundant with cows, horses, rabbits, sheep and stags, a multitude of birds, but no pigs.

There had previously been many cities and large towns, but these were now destroyed (although no reason was given). Now, all that remained were a few habitants, who possessed little or no corn.

Following the celebrations, the crew made their way back to the ship with their rewards, having been given directions to find their way back to Ireland.

They set sail immediately and, the next evening, as darkness was falling, they found themselves approaching their home port of Killybegs, in the county of Donegall.

Three days later, Alexander Johnson, the Master of Nisbet’s ship, together with members of the initial landing party, set sail to the island again. The crew including a handful of other sailors who’d made the original journey, together with a sponsor, who wanted to see if the story was indeed true.

Upon landing, as before, they were again richly entertained.

This was followed by further voyagers, which by now included members of the clergy, although the author of the letter, Hamilton, had yet to learn how these visits were received by the islanders, as the voyages were possibly still in progress.

Hamilton closed his letter (to his cousin) by asserting that he’d been told the account personally, by no less than Captain Nisbet himself and, several other gentlemen who’d since made the journey to Hy-Brasil.

He also attested some of the gentlemen had even confirmed the account in writing, in their own hand and using their seals, before passing them on to dignitaries in Dublin.

The Roderic O’Flaherty Account
Another reference, contemporary to Nisbet’s visit, was documented in 1684, providing a further addition to the Hy-Brasil narrative, with the publication of O’Flahery’s book, A Chorographical Description of West or H-Iar Connaught (4).

In his book, O’Flaherty tells us the story of Morogh O’Ley (also known as Lee or Lye), who claimed to be in the possession of the book known as the ‘Book of O’Brazil’, having received it directly from the inhabitants of the island on a previous visit he’d made, some years prior to 1648.

When examined, the book was shown to be a medical manuscript, published on vellum (animal skin) and well written in both Latin and Irish, consisting of 46 pages and written sometime in the 15th Century, as evidenced by an entry in the book referring to the year 1434.

Curiously, O’Flaherty ends his account by stating The ‘Book of O’Brazil’ is now preserved in the library of the Royal Irish Academy, although I’ve still yet to research this tantalising line of enquiry. 

The end of an era…. T J Westroop and the final sghting
The final recorded sighting of Hy-Brasil allegedly occurred in 1872, now almost 200 years after Nisbet’s adventure, by TJ Westropp, who was author of several books relating to Irish antiquities and ancient sites.

After reporting his sighting, Westropp would later go on to announce he’d actually visited the island on three occasions, the final time with his mother and some close friends, who he’d taken along on the voyage so they would believe him. As with Captain Nisbet, they all observed it appearing out of nowhere, before seeing it disappear for the final time, not just for the assembled group personally, but perhaps also from the annals of maritime history, where only a year later, in 1873, it was recorded for the final time on a British Admiralty Chart.

Separating facts from the myths
However, what can be gleaned from the all the folklore and accounts written about Hy-Brasil?

Re-examining the source material I used, I made a list of some common factors:

  • Hy-Brasil is difficult to find or pinpoint its location.
  • It spends much of its time shrouded in a bank of thick mist or fog, only to suddenly reveal itself as vessels draw near.
  • It may only be visible every seven years or so.
  • It’s roughly about twice the size of the Isle of Man, off the coast of north west England.
  • The population is greatly reduced from historical times, due to some unspecified disaster.
  • The people there are generally welcoming and friendly.
  • The livestock and crops are similar to that found in the neighbouring British Isles.
  • No apparent mythical creatures or cryptids, in spite of the writings of many other writers; and
  • The native language appears to be Scottish Gaelic, although Latin and Irish Gaelic is present in their writings.

After considering this list, apart from the tradition the island was only visible every seven years (at traditional ‘long period’ in folklore terms), the other factors listed appear to be a reasonable given for an island situated off the west coast of Ireland, no claims of unicorns, dragons or even giant rabbits. Is it therefore beyond the realms of possibility that we may be discussing a genuine island that was lost to the world some time ago in ancient history? 

Hy-Brasil – the evidence provided by historical maps?
Whilst there exists few maps which mention Atlantis, this lost Island, along with its equally lost twin Demar, frequently appeared on early, historical maps of the eastern Atlantic Ocean, right through and up to the end of the 19th Century, where in 1873 it appeared on the British Admiralty chart for the very last time.

We have already touched upon Angelino Dalorto’s nautical chart of 1325CE in the opening paragraph and we can see, by studying the historical maps and charts still available to us now, both the lost islands frequently appear on many historical maps, including:

1436 – Andrea Bianco (Insula de Brasil) – title for image
1562 – Diego Gutierrrez (Isola de Brazil)
1570 – Abraham Ortelius (Brasil)
1588 – Sebastian Munster (Brasil)

1630 – Joao Teixeira Albernaz (Do Brasil)

1763 – Thomas Jefferys (Imaginary Isle of O’Brazil – clearly doubts were beginning to set in at this stage)

1769 – Guillaume de L’Isle (Rocher de Brasil)

Two of these maps are reproduced below, as sample illustrations

Abraham-Ortelius Map - 1570
Detail from Abraham Ortelius’ map ‘Theatrum Orbis Terrarum’ 1570
The Sebastian Munster Map of 1588
Detail from the Sebastian Munster Map of 1588

In relation to Hy-Brasil’s appearance on maps, it has long been recognised that many historical maps now in the public domain were based upon far earlier maps and charts which are no longer available and, in reality, no longer exist.

Probably the best example of this is the 1513 Piri Reis map, named after its creator, a Captain in the Turkish Fleet (later Admiral), discovered in a Turkish Palace in 1929.

The Piri Reis map is notable for including lands and features yet to be discovered in 1513, including the Andes Mountains of South America and, more astonishingly Antarctica, ice free, which was only ‘discovered’ in modern times, some 305 years later, in 1818.

Piri Reis Map, 1513
Piri Reis Map 1513, showing the Andes (lower left) and, the coastline of ice-free Antarctica (bottom)

Piri (‘Reis’ translates as ‘Captain’) cited twenty other maps he drew upon as his sources, some dating as far back to the time of Alexander the Great (356 – 323BCE).

However, this was not to say Hy-Brasil was ignored, as discussed earlier, expeditions were being launched in the 15th Century on the basis of the information shown on the maps, to try and finally locate the mysterious land, once and for all and, open up new trade avenues.  

 

Today……. Technologic advancements and Science
From what we’ve covered above, it can be seen that interest in Hy-Brasil piqued in the late 19th Century, with any further interest being restricted to the realms of Irish folklore and legend.

However, with the development of modern technology over the past 100 years or so, including the general availability of satellite imagery, have we moved anywhere nearer to establishing if there really was a Hy-Brasil, or even its sister island Demar?

In 1870, a paper was presented to the Royal Geological Society of Ireland by W Frazer, suggesting Hy-Brasil was located within the Porcupine Bank, an underwater feature some 124 miles west of Ireland that had been discovered eight years earlier in 1862 (8).

This was followed up once again by Frazer, in the December 1883 issue of Notes and Queries, referring to another paper he had presented to the Royal Geological Society of Ireland in 1879, suggesting once again the island of Hy Brasil was located in the Porcupine Bank, based upon a manuscript map published by the Geographer Royal, le Sieur Tassin in 1634 (9).

In 2013, respected marine biologist and rare fish expert, Declan Quigly went public on his suspicions the Porcupine Bank was the location of Hy-Brasil, before it was lost to rising sea levels following the last Ice Age. Quigly pointed out that the Bank was only 200 metres deep, with the pre Ice Age sea level calculated to be around 120 metres lower than it is today (10).

What is immediately notable here is, following the discovery of the Porcupine Bank in 1862, public interest in Hy Brasil almost immediately re-surfaced (apologies, I couldn’t resist myself there…), so let’s take a closer look at what the Porcupine Bank has to offer us in the way of the Hy Brasil (and Demar) legends

The Porcupine Bank
Today, the Porcupine Bank is a raised area of seabed located some 124 miles (200 kilometres) off the western coast of Ireland. Only 200 metres below the surface at its highest point, it lies between the deepwater troughs of Porcupine Seabright and, Rockall Trough.

Map of the seabed west of Britain and Ireland
Map of the seabed, showing the Porcupine Bank, left of Ireland

The Bank itself was named in honour after HMS Porcupine, the vessel upon which its discovery was made, in 1862.

In support of the sunken island hypothesis, it has been suggested that both Hy-Brasil and Demar lay along what is now the Porcupine Bank, before being lost during the last Ice Age.

This could have been caused by either rising sea water due to the melting ice, or catastrophic land movement causing the islands to sink beneath the waves (remember the wizened old man on Hy-Brasil who claimed that the island used to have many large cities and a far greater population before a catastrophe hit), or even possibly a combination of both.

Whilst this hypothesis sound fantastical, it would be wise to recall that there is much geological evidence of historical landmass changes on the west coast of Britain such as in the region of the Isles of Scilly and, numerous ancient Welsh legends of much lost land due to massive floods and tsunamis, therefore it is difficult to dismiss this hypothesis outright.

It is also now possible for us to take a closer look at the Porcupine Bank ourselves, thanks to the satellite imagery used by numerous software programmes and freely available to anyone with an internet connection, which in addition to providing imagery of the land masses, also provides rudimentary imagery of the seabed.


Satellite Imagery – the tool of discoverers
Using Google Earth (11), we can now explore the seabed of the Porcupine Bank from the safety of our own homes without having to get our feet wet.

Moving around the area around the western side of the Bank, towards the middle, we can see two prominent features leaping out from the seabed:


Hy-Brasil and its sister island Demar?
Hy-Brasil and its sister island Demar?

In the above composite image, I’ve provided a shot of the area of interest to the left, with a second image of exactly the same shot on the right, that highlights the two prominent features mentioned in the previous above. On the left hand side of each image you can make out two features that closely resemble the islands of Hy-Brasil and Demar, including the seemingly correct distance between the two usually depicted on maps.

Below, I’ve created a composite image, comparing the adjusted satellite image on the left, with the similar area from the Sebastian Munster Map of 1588 on the right. If you examine the two carefully, you can clearly see a resemblance between the two images, both in the shape of Hy-Brasil and Demar, but also in the relationship between their respective positions.

Adjusted satellite image of Hy-Brasil and Demar (left) in comparison to their illustration on the Sebastian Munster map of 1588
Adjusted satellite image of Hy-Brasil and Demar (left) in comparison to their illustration on the Sebastian Munster map of 1588

At this point, it would be remiss of me to ignore a more contemporary incident that brought Hy-Brazil back into popular culture, the incident I refer to is none other than the Rendlesham Forest UFO incident which occurred in December 1980, on the east coast of England in sleepy Suffolk. 

Jim Penniston and the Rendlesham Forest UFO landing
For those not already familiar with the incident, in December 1980, on Boxing Day (26th), a UFO allegedly landed in Rendlesham Forest, near to the East Gate of RAF Woodbridge, a former military airbase, in the possession of the United States Air Force at the time.

The extraterrestrial craft which landed was witnessed by a search party sent out from the airbase, with an audio recording of the whole event allegedly made, by Lieutenant Colonel Charles Halt, the deputy base commander, who was a member of the search party. This tape subsequently made its way into the public domain which has been generally referred to as ‘The Holt Tape’ (5).

Rendlesham Forest, Suffolk, with the former RAF Bentwaters Airbase middle top, and the RAF Woodbridge runway clearly visible in the centre of the forest – Google Earth
Rendlesham Forest, Suffolk, with the former RAF Bentwaters Airbase middle top, and the RAF Woodbridge runway clearly visible in the centre of the forest – Google Earth

As years passed, other witnesses to the alleged event came forward, including Sergeant Jim Penniston, who revealed not only had he approached the craft and touched it, by some telegraphic process, he’d somehow ‘downloaded’ many pages of binary code to his consciousness (6) (7).

Thankfully, Penniston had the sense of mind to commit to paper the codes the following day, but many years were to pass before it was finally ‘translated’ and revealed publically, on the 30th Anniversary of the incident, in 2010.

In an anniversary update in 2010, Penniston revealed the code to be a list of coordinates for a handful  of ancient sites dotted around the world, such as the Great Pyramid, in Giza, Sedona, in Arizona, the Nazca Lines, in Peru and, including a seemingly empty location in the Atlantic Ocean, off the west coast of Ireland.

The coordinates for the ‘empty’ location being  52.0942532 N, 13.131269 W .

However, before we discuss these co-ordinates, it is important to stress there are many inconsistencies in Penniston’s story.

I find it difficult to ignore that the co-ordinates were missing from his notebook, when he was filmed showing it to Lieutenant Colonel Charles Halt years after the event, before they suddenly appeared to be revealed publicly in time for the 30th anniversary. This is troubling if we are to consider the bigger picture surrounding his version of events.

However, for the sake of debate and completeness, we shall examine the implications of Penniston’s binary code, which was converted into a set of coordinates, of which one, 52.0942532 N, 13.131269 W, indicated a spot in the Atlantic Ocean, off the west coast of Ireland.

If we place these coordinates into Google Earth, we get the following result:

Jim Penniston’s coordinates of 53.0942532 N, 13.131269 W compared to the seabed position of Hy-Brasil and Demar – Google Earth
Jim Penniston’s coordinates of 53.0942532 N, 13.131269 W compared to the seabed position of Hy-Brasil and Demar – Google Earth

Whilst Penniston’s coordinates are to the east of Hy-Brasil and Demar seen on the Porcupine Bank, remarkably, it’s approximately 55 miles equidistant to the two islands from this point. Is this coincidental?

If we believe Penniston’s account, were the visitors to Rendlesham Forest that night attempting to reveal to humanity the secret location of Hy-Brasil or, was something else at play?

On reflection, no matter what the latest satellite imagery shows, whether it reveals the former locations of Hy-Brasil and Demar or not, they most certainly provide much food for thought.

Even more so, what is most remarkable, is not only are we able to confirm the position of two lost islands, not just one, simply by using satellite imagery which match historical descriptions and, not only that, they appear to be exactly in the locations the maps and legends placed them.

Again, is this just purely coincidental, a chance event?

Geological Studies
In 2016, a group of scientists released a paper of their study of the seabed geomorphology of the Porcupine Bank (12). In the paper, they highlight two outcrops of bedrock in the area we have already identified as being the locations of Hy Brasil and Demar.

Seabed Geomorphology of the Porcupine Bank, featuring Hy-Brasil and Demar – © 2015 Benjamin Thébaudeau
Seabed Geomorphology of the Porcupine Bank, featuring Hy-Brasil and Demar – © 2015 Benjamin Thébaudeau

The northern outcrop, we are identifying as Hy-Brasil for the purpose of this article, is described in the paper as ‘A conical mound with a central depression occurs on the southern part of the bank between 340 and 350m water depth. This feature has an elliptical ridge with a major axis of 7km and a minor of 5km…’

The southern outcrop, we are identifying as Demar for the purpose of this article, is described in the paper as ‘A cluster of low mounds and ridges…. between 340 and 360m in depth, with a total area of 140km square.’

Furthermore, if you look closely in the image, at the seabed around the area of the northern outcrop, you can make out two fault lines, possibly indicating a catastrophic geological upheaval, resulting in the loss of both islands, as opposed to rising sea levels following the end of the Ice Age, as has been previously proposed.

 

Conclusions
Although the legends, folklore and cartography featuring the lost islands of Hy-Brasil and Demar have been considered as no more than mythical islands that never had any basis in fact, it’s clear that, when examining all the available data to us though a modern lens, there does appear to be some supporting evidence to make a case that it is possible for these two legendary islands to have once existed. Distant memories of mankind, recalled through stories and legends, remembered through stories told around burning campfires, on cold winter nights, or through dusty old tomes that taken together, mat preserve a memory of genuine landforms now lost beneath the Atlantic.

I hope that I’ve been able to show here is, by not just relying solely on isolated aspects of the story – the folklore and legends, the cartographers of history, satellite imagery or with science by geological surveys, but by combining ALL the data, we can show, that it’s possible that two islands had once existed in the eastern Atlantic, off the west coast of Ireland.

Taking this one step further, if we are to accept the latest findings of what science has to offer us and, we have now found and proved the correct location of these mystical islands, the remaining mystery left to us is to establish when it was likely the islands were lost to the world.

Perhaps, one day, even this information will become available to us.

Only time will tell.

References:

  1. Plato – Timaeus and Critias dialogues, 360BCE
  2. The tour of the French traveller M. de La Boullaye Le Gouz in Ireland, A.D. 1644 (pub.1957) (http://research.ucc.ie/celt/document/T100076?segment=2)
  3. The tour of the French traveller M. de La Boullaye Le Gouz in Ireland, A.D. 1644 (p.70).
  4. Roderic O’Flaherty – A Chorographical Description of West or H-Iar Connaught (1684) (p.69)
  5. Col. Charles Holt – The Halt Tape – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZZtidhZbcE
  6. Nick Pope, John Burroughs & Jim Penniston – Encounter in Rendlesham Forest (2014)
  7. Jim Penniston & Gary Osborn – The Rendlesham Enigma: Book 1: Timeline (2015)
  8. Fraser – Geological Society of Ireland (20th January 1870)
  9. Frazer – Notes and Queries Vol s6-VIII, issue 207 15th December 1883, p.474-5
  10. Lorna Siggins – Exotic Porcupine Bank catch nets second coconut – The Irish Times, 17th August 2013 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/ireland/irish-news/exotic-porcupine-bank-catch-nets-second-coconut-1.1496847
  11. Other satellite imagery applications are available.
  12. Benjamin Thébaudeau, Xavier Monteys, Stephen McCarron, Ronan O’Toole & Silvia Caloca (2016) Seabed geomorphology of the Porcupine Bank, West of Ireland, Journal of Maps, 12:5, 947-958, DOI: 10.1080/17445647.2015.1099573 https://doi.org/10.1080/17445647.2015.1099573